top of page

Unravelling Pakistan’s Polyrisis

Writer: Saleem Qamar Butt
Saleem Qamar Butt
11 minutes ago
4 min read

Plato warned over two millennia ago that "the price good men pay for indifference to public affairs is to be ruled by evil men." Few modern states illustrate this caution as starkly as Pakistan. Born of an idealistic vision—a constitutional, democratic welfare state anchored in social justice and rule of law—the republic today stands entangled in an interlocking web of political decay, economic insolvency, institutional erosion, and internal insecurity. When surveying the wreckage of squandered potential, the dilemma is not finding a fault line, but deciding where to begin.

At the root of this malaise lies a profound drift from the state’s founding ethos. Rather than nurturing representative governance accountable to citizens, Pakistan’s political order has succumbed to elite capture. Usurpers from entrenched oligarchies, dynastic political fiefdoms, and unelected power centers have colonized state institutions. Within this architecture, hierarchical political parties operate less as vehicles of policy and more as syndicates of mutual survival, switching alliances by hook or by crook whenever patronage shifts. When political victimization replaces parliamentary debate and merit is massacred at the altar of nepotism, statecraft degenerates into self-preservation. As the Urdu proverb aptly captures this moral bankruptcy, "Jis ki laathi, us ki bhains"—might makes right, while justice, education, healthcare, and human capital development remain afterthoughts.

This chronic misgovernance finds its sharpest expression in an addiction to borrowed lifelines. Instead of expanding the domestic tax net or building export capacity, successive regimes have mortgaged national sovereignty to creditors—pouring billions into vanity projects far removed from food, water, and energy security. By the close of FY2025–26, Pakistan’s external public debt reached $98.08 billion, while domestic public debt ballooned to Rs59.44 trillion. In a single fiscal year, Pakistan spent $14.44 billion merely servicing external debt—nearly half of its $30.14 billion in merchandise exports, leaving a $39.62 billion trade deficit. Tellingly, 58 percent of foreign economic assistance in FY26 went toward budgetary and balance-of-payments survival rather than productive assets. From surging debt and punitive energy tariffs to worsening insecurity, Pakistan’s poly-crisis is a self-inflicted departure from its founding ethos—one that no IMF tranche can cure without structural reform.

Living on borrowed money forfeits economic sovereignty. Stabilisation programmes prescribed by the International Monetary Fund (IMF) and World Bank—often blunt instruments demanding immediate tax hikes and subsidy withdrawals without elite reform—have squeezed an anaemic economy. While headline GDP growth hovered at 3.7 percent in FY26, population growth eroded per capita gains, pushing national poverty from 22 percent in 2018–19 to 29 percent. With 70 million citizens below the poverty line and debt servicing devouring half of export earnings, survival politics must give way to genuine statesmanship.

Nowhere is policy paralysis more punishing than in the energy sector, where capacity payments, circular debt, and punitive taxes have priced Pakistani industry out of global markets. While industrial power tariffs across South Asian peers—India (averaging $0.07 per kWh), Nepal ($0.10), and Bangladesh ($0.12)—foster competitiveness, Pakistan’s industrial tariffs hovered at $0.14 to $0.16 per unit, forcing authorities in November 2026 to notify a revised incremental tariff of Rs25.30 per unit to revive collapsing industrial demand. Factories crippled by energy costs cannot compete regionally, nor can the economy generate the 3.5 million jobs needed annually for its youth.

Compound economic strangulation with deteriorating internal security, and the fragility of the social contract becomes unmistakable. Following a 74 percent surge in counterterrorism casualties in 2025, militancy remained entrenched into 2026—with the second quarter of 2026 alone recording 774 violence-linked fatalities across 267 incidents, largely in Khyber Pakhtunkhwa and Balochistan. Insecurity chills investment, drains funds from schools and hospitals, and deepens provincial alienation. Bloated public debt, South Asia’s highest industrial power tariffs, and rising militancy threaten the social contract of a nuclear-armed nation of 240 million.

Ibn Khaldun observed in his Muqaddimah that states collapse not merely from external blows, but from internal rot—when injustice destroys the incentive to produce, taxation turns confiscatory, and social solidarity (asabiyyah) dissolves into factional greed. Today, Pakistan lives out the grim adage: "A hungry man has no religion." When inflation erodes wages and courts fail to deliver timely justice, civic morality and globally accepted ethical norms collapse. Corruption ceases to be a scandal and becomes a coping mechanism. Echoing Ibn Khaldun’s warning on internal rot, decades of nepotism, elite privilege, and externally dictated austerity have eroded both economic sovereignty and civic norms. Until Islamabad dismantles entrenched monopolies, tames runaway energy costs, and restores the rule of law, foreign bailouts will only prolong the reckoning. 

Yet history offers no exemption for despair. Nations reform not when lenders demand it, but when ruling classes realize the status quo is unsustainable. Escaping this abyss demands a structural reset: dismantling elite privileges, renegotiating crippling energy contracts, restoring meritocracy across the civil service and judiciary, empowering local governments, and anchoring foreign policy in economic diplomacy rather than geopolitical rent-seeking. As the proverb warns, "A stitch in time saves nine." Pakistan possesses the demographic energy, agrarian potential, and strategic geography to recover—provided it finally chooses statesmanship over survival. Pakistan Zindabad!

 

 
 
 

Comments


bottom of page